Top 5 Best Sleep Mask for Ultimate Comfort and Darkness in 2025

If even the smallest bit of light sneaking in ruins your sleep, you’re not alone. Whether it’s streetlights outside your window, a partner scrolling on their phone, or early morning sunbeams waking you up before your alarm, light can seriously mess with your rest.

That is where a great sleep mask comes in. It is the easiest and cheapest solution to block out brightness and sleep better. However, not all sleep masks are the same. Some fall off in the middle of the night, some rest too heavily on your eyes, and some do not completely block light as stated.

So we did the digging for you. After testing a variety of styles—silk, memory foam, contoured, and flat—we’ve rounded up the top sleep masks that actually stay in place, block out light, and feel comfortable enough to wear every night.

Best Sleep Masks 

1. Evercool® Cooling Eye Mask

This eye mask is a game-changer if you tend to overheat at night. Made with Rest’s proprietary Evercool® fabric, it feels instantly cool to the touch—thanks to its high Qmax (0.40), it outperforms cotton, silk, and bamboo in staying refreshingly cool. From the moment it lands on your skin, you get that soothing chill that sets the tone for sleep.

What we love is its wrap-around design. It covers your entire eye area, gently hugging your face to block light effectively without pressing on your eyes. The wide, adjustable strap means it stays put all night and won’t tug at your hair. Plus, it’s machine-washable—and it bounces back from the washer just fine, with no pilling or losing shape—so care is easy, too.

Pros

• An immediate cooling sensation is perfect for warm sleepers

• Full-face wrap blocks light well without feeling tight

• Breathable, soft fabric that doesn’t trap heat

• Adjustable strap stays comfortable and secure

• Easy to clean (machine/dryer safe) and durable

Cons

• Some light may seep around the nose unless the fit is precise

• Thicker than flat silk masks

2. Alaska Bear Natural Silk Sleep Mask

This one’s a crowd favorite for a reason. The Alaska Bear sleep mask is double-lined using mulberry silk; thus, the sleep mask is exceptionally smooth, cool, and breathable against the face. It does not trap heat, so it is ideal when you run hot at night.

The best part about it is the fact that the design is flat, hence it won't easily roll off, even when you are a stomach sleeper. No awkward bunching or pressure on your eyes—just soft, lightweight coverage that blocks out a decent amount of light.  It is not a 100% blackout, but it does the trick with most people.

It comes with an adjustable strap that is thin and discreet, with a small plastic buckle that fits most hairstyles or head sizes. I mean, it is one of those masks that you do not remember having on until the next day when you wake up.

Pros

• Breathable silk keeps your face cool

• Gentle on skin and lashes

• Stays put in most sleep positions

• Adjustable strap doesn't tangle or pull

Cons

• It can slip off if worn loosely

• A thin strap may irritate sensitive skin

• Requires hand washing

3. Mzoo Sleep Mask

If you prefer total darkness and despise things touching your eyelids, the Mzoo mask would be worth trying. It is made of memory foam, and the contour is modeled by deep eye cups that fit around your eyes, not on your eyes. This means that you can blink, flutter, or wear lash extensions without ruining anything.

The foam hugs your face and is highly light-blocking. It is amazing to sleep on your back or side and not have any glaring light escaping. The mask itself is also pleasantly tough and has a broad, adjustable elastic strap easily loosened or tightened with a slider.

With that said, it is a little chunkier than silk masks so if you have a small head it may still feel loose even when pulled tight. Few users complained that the foam press pressed too much than it should at the cheekbones or temples, so bear in mind in case you are sensitive to pressure.

Pros

• Memory foam eye cups don’t press on eyelids

• Excellent light blocking

• Great for back and side sleepers

• The strap is wide and adjustable

Cons

• Bulkier than flat masks

• May feel tight around some facial areas

• Needs to be hand-washed

4. Nidra Deep Rest Eye Mask

The mask makes a lot of sense when you desire something rather structured yet incredibly lightweight. The Nidra Deep Rest has wide, curved eye cups that would not be in contact with your eyes altogether, thus will in no way interfere with lashes or eye movement throughout your slumber. It is a soft and light material, and the design is more extensive than many, temple to temple.

The slanted nose piece aids the defense against the light leaks, and the elastic band (with a plastic slider) keeps the mask in place vs. the velcro catching your hair. It packs away small, should be travel-friendly, and it still provides you with that charming blackout feeling.

Remember that it is a fantastic option for back and upright sleepers, but it does not get along with stomach sleepers. The elevated eye cups may move or become uncomfortable when you sleep with your head partially on the pillow. Moreover, the edges of the eye area could be slightly scratchy to some users.

Pros

• Deep cups let your eyes move freely

• Lightweight and travel-ready

• Blocks out light well across the face

• Adjustable and stays put

Cons

• Not ideal for stomach sleepers

• Material edges may feel rough

• Needs gentle hand washing

5. Manta Sleep Mask

The Manta Sleep Mask might just become your new favorite sleep mask- especially if you have ever struggled to find a sleep mask that properly fits YOUR face. What makes it different is that the eye cups are completely adjustable- yes, the cups are Velcro-backed and can be arranged anywhere they need to be. This means no more light seeping in at the nose bridge and sides, and no strain on the eyes.

The eye cups are thick and doughnut-shaped, providing extra cushioning and no lash interference whatsoever. They also have a nice blackout effect, even in daytime naps and on the road. It is slightly bulkier than flat masks, but that may be a worthwhile trade-off for a back sleeper or one who would like complete darkness.

Simply remember that it is not the best breathable mask on the market. It may also become hot in summer or when you are a sweaty sleeper. The Velcro has flexibility too, but it may not be the best option if you toss and turn a lot; it can move a little bit between nights.

Pros

• Fully adjustable eye cups for a custom fit

• Great light blocking, even in bright rooms

• No pressure on eyes or lashes

• Solid choice for frequent travelers or daytime sleepers

Cons

• Bulkier than most masks

• Fabric can trap heat

• Velcro may shift slightly during the night

How to Pick a Sleep Mask You’ll Use Every Night

1. Blocks Light Properly

A sleep mask isn’t doing much if light still sneaks in. Some fit too loosely around the nose or don’t hug the face evenly, letting the glow from streetlights or sunrise ruin your rest. If you’re sensitive to light, go for one that shapes well to your face or has a contoured design to keep things truly dark. It’s especially worth it if you’ve already set up a calming space with cozy bedding, or blackout curtains—every little bit helps.

2. Feels Good on Your Skin

You’ll be wearing this for hours, so comfort matters. Fabrics like silk and bamboo feel soft and breathable—great if you run warm at night. Memory foam is cushy, but it can trap heat. If a mask feels rough or stuffy, chances are you won’t keep it on for long.

3. Stays in Place Without Bugging You

Straps seem like a small detail, but they can make or break the experience. Adjustable straps with sliders tend to be the most comfortable. Velcro can work too, but it might tug your hair or lose grip over time. The goal is a secure fit that doesn’t dig in or shift around.

4. Comfort

Some people are fine with fabric resting right on their eyelids—others find it distracting or uncomfortable. If that’s you, look for a mask with deeper eye cups or a contoured shape. These give your eyes space to blink and move naturally without pressure, which is especially nice if you wear lash extensions.

5. Matches Your Sleep Position

Back sleepers can use pretty much any mask. But if you sleep on your side or stomach, a bulky one will just get in the way. You’ll want something flatter and more flexible so it doesn’t press into your face or shift when your head hits the pillow.

6. Easy to Wash and Maintain

Since sleep masks sit right against your skin, they need regular washing. Some are machine-friendly, while others, especially silk, need hand-washing. If you’re not up for delicate care, make sure your mask can handle frequent cleaning without falling apart.

Final Take

Sleep does not always come easily, particularly when you have light to disturb your sleep. However, the right sleep mask can really make a difference. It does not need to be fancy or cost a lot; it just must be well-fitting, and you must like it on your skin, and it must keep the light out.

Everyone’s preferences differ, so don’t stress if the first one you try isn’t perfect. Pay attention to what matters most: total darkness, cooling fabric, or a strap that doesn’t dig in. Once you find a mask that checks your boxes, bedtime gets easier, and sleep starts to feel like something you look forward to.

Better rest might be just a sleep mask away.